6 Jan – MBS Alumni Toastmaster Club – The Secret to a Meaningful Evaluation
|
Do you remember the best, or the worst, feedback you ever received? What made it remarkable?
|
We evaluate, give and receive feedback at work everyday.
|
According to TED speaker LeeAnn Renninger, a study showed that only 26% of workers remembered & felt feedback improved their work performance.
|
This low figure is because the feedback given was not brain friendly enough. It was either too soft and indirect so the brain did not recognise it or was confused; or it was too aggressive, direct and critical and the brain shut-down, sensing an attack & turned to defence mode.
|
To give great feedback she suggests we:
|
1. Ask a short or important question at the beginning which requires an answer (to let the respondent’s brain get ready to start)
|
2. Give specific points with examples (instead of a vague statement)
|
3. Elaborate the feedback by highlighting its impact
|
4.End with a question such as: What are your thoughts on this? Do you see it?
|
After discussion among ourselves, we generated these insights:
|
1.Don’t give all feedback in one-go
|
2.Give critical feedback privately
|
3.Use storytelling when talking to seniors
|
4.Avoid sensitive issues & cultural taboos
|
5.Control stress and temper
|
Give ACCLAIM to Pappu and Jason who took up these two important meeting roles for the first time - Toastmaster of the Evening and Table Topics Master - respectively. Well done, guys!
|
Evaluation |
|
|